The ongoing ODI World Cup 2023 has showcased the evolution of modern-day cricket in numerous ways, reshaping the game from its traditional roots. Among the many changes, the Decision Review System (DRS) stands out as a pivotal innovation that has fundamentally altered the way cricket is approached. In the past, the umpire’s decision was considered final, but DRS has injected a new dimension into the game, offering a lifeline to players dissatisfied with on-field judgments.
While the DRS has undoubtedly been a successful addition to the sport, it is not without its controversies. One contentious aspect of the DRS is the ‘Umpire’s Call’ rule, which allows the on-field umpire’s decision to influence the outcome of a DRS review. This rule has been a subject of debate and frustration among players, pundits, and fans.
In a recent World Cup match between South Africa and Pakistan, the ‘Umpire’s Call’ rule took centre stage and played a critical role in determining the game’s outcome. South Africa found themselves in a precarious situation with nine wickets down while chasing Pakistan’s target. Tabraiz Shamsi, facing a tricky LBW decision after being hit on the pads, witnessed an instant appeal from the Pakistani players. However, the on-field umpire did not uphold the appeal, believing that the ball was missing the leg stump.
Upon Pakistan’s referral to the DRS, the giant screen displayed a different story, showing that the ball was indeed hitting the stumps. Despite the technology-backed evidence, the batsman was declared not out, as the on-field umpire had initially ruled in favour of the batsman. This incident has triggered a wave of speculation and calls for a change in the ‘Umpire’s Call’ rule, even from former players.
Umpire’s Call under scrutiny: Harbhajan Singh’s plea for rule change!
Harbhajan Singh, India’s legendary spinner, took to social media to express his discontent with the ‘Umpire’s Call’ rule. He stated, “Bad umpiring and bad rules cost Pakistan this game, ICC should change this rule… if the ball is hitting the stump, that’s out, whether the umpire gave out or not out doesn’t matter… otherwise what is the use of technology???”
Bad umpiring and bad rules cost Pakistan this game.. @ICC should change this rule .. if the ball is hitting the stump that’s out whether umpire gave out or not out doesn’t matter.. otherwise what is the use of technology??? @TheRealPCB vs #SouthAfrica #worldcup
— Harbhajan Turbanator (@harbhajan_singh) October 27, 2023
Singh’s tweet has elicited a myriad of responses from the cricketing community, sparking discussions about the necessity for rule amendments within the DRS framework.
The controversy surrounding ‘Umpire’s Call’ highlights the complex balance between technology and the on-field umpire’s authority. While the DRS was introduced to ensure fairness and accuracy in decision-making, incidents like the one in the South Africa vs. Pakistan match underscore the need for a more comprehensive review of the system’s rules. The cricketing world is in a state of flux, torn between tradition and technology, and the conversation on the ‘Umpire’s Call’ rule is likely to persist, with potential changes on the horizon to uphold the spirit of fairness and precision that the DRS was meant to bring to the game.
Look at how the fans have reacted:
Paaji hum bachpan se hi sune hai ki umpire's decision is final decision. Abhi kese change karde
— Shreyofhope (@PatnaikShreya98) October 28, 2023
— Chhichhaledar (@chhichhaledar) October 27, 2023
— Gagan?? (@1no_aalsi_) October 27, 2023
And what about this bhajji paaji? pic.twitter.com/JTtgTEj04G
— R A T N I S H (@LoyalSachinFan) October 27, 2023
What is the use of an umpire ?
Why not play robots instead of playersDon't fight illogical
— Sandiiip (@IndiaUnleashed_) October 27, 2023
Sir Aapko Lahore Chorh aau? pic.twitter.com/2KpqmUNpTm
— Vivek Singh (@VivekSi85847001) October 27, 2023
Are you lacking in sense or unconditionally supporting Pakistan? Rassie's decesion was even more erroneous than Shamsi's. It seems that you are making such stupid remarks merely to appease certain Pakistani followers. pic.twitter.com/sKlEJLdNqt
— Shailesh (@HindustaniTweet) October 27, 2023
— Rohit K (@RohitInExile) October 27, 2023
No disrespect to Sir, but looks like Bhajji isn't aware of the "margin of error" and why this IMPACT CALL is actually in rules.
It is their to not correct the umpires but technology.
It's a prediction that ball will hit the stumps, it may or may not be accurate.
— Cric Point (@RealCricPoint) October 27, 2023
